Book Report: Our highly scientific analysis of a book, from the characters to the writing style to the swoon. See More...

Skull and Bones Got Nothing on This Crew

A boarding school with a secrety society? Consider Mandy W. intrigued by Lizzie Friend's Poor Little Dead Girls. (When it wasn't offending her feminist sensibilities, that is.)

Skull and Bones Got Nothing on This Crew

BOOK REPORT for Poor Little Dead Girls by Lizzie Friend

Cover Story: Textile-tastic
BFF Charm: Natalie Imbruglia
Swoonworthy Scale: 1
Talky Talk: Ms. Norbury Intervention Required
Bonus Factors: Boarding School, Secret Society
Relationship Status: Frenemies

Cover Story: Textile-tastic

GASP! What's this? Nary a face nor disembodied figure in sight?! And to top it off, the cover actually looks good, too?! It also gives little glimpses of what the book involves: a set of lockers, a lacrosse field, and a uniform. I can't quite remember what the nondescript building has to do with anything, but three out of four ain't bad! The only criticism I have is for the tagline; what the heck are murder games? The only thing that comes to mind is the board game, Clue. And the Hunger Games, obvs.

The Deal:

Sadie Marlowe is starting her junior year at the prestigious Keating Hall on a lacrosse scholarship. Emphasis on 'prestigious' -- her classmates include offsprings of the nation's elite. And they all want Sadie to join their inner circle. The high life sure looks enticing: cool parties, hot boys, and amazing connections. Everything Sadie ever wanted could be at her fingertips -- but at what cost? 

BFF Charm: Natalie Imbruglia

I'm torn, y'all. Sadie has a touch of Mary Sue-ness, yet she isn't afraid to speak her mind -- occasionally to amusing effect. But she's SO down on her middle-class roots. I get that the environment at Keating must be intimidating, but Sadie feels like she's from some podunk, middle-of-nowhere hick town -- a perception shared by everyone else. Girl. You're from Portland. It may not be the party capital of the world, but it's still a pretty big deal. It'd make a lot more sense if you were accused of being a hipster; instead, everyone's associating Portlanders with being ass-backwards rubes, I really don't know why. Is there some Americans-only secret about Portland that I don't know about? LEAVE PORTLAND ALONE, YOU GUYS. 

Swoonworthy Scale: 1

Roger Murtaugh usually only weighs in for the BFF section, but y'all -- I'm too old for this relationshizz. There's probably more swoon in this book for someone else, but I just COULD NOT with Jeremy. He is, of course, extremely dreamy-looking, and he and Sadie bond over being this year's new kids. But the dude uses bra sizes as a flirtation technique -- and he's successful. Sorry, Jeremy. You probably have relatively little experience in handling them, so the way to my heart is not through the breasts, thanks. 

Talky Talk: Ms. Norbury Intervention Required

So the good: the plot moves briskly and it goes down easy. But on the subject of another kind of 'easy' -- OY WITH THE POODLES ALREADY.

These kids -- these girls -- carelessly toss around words like slutty, skanky, trashy, and the ilk. Some even do it in a supposedly endearing way. But it's problematic when the people using these terms can't differentiate between subverting and plain ol' perpetuating the tired and damaging stereotypes about sexuality. A freshman girl gets caught in a senior boy's room? She gets whisked away in quiet shame, and her former classmates dub her jailbait. (No fallout for the guy, natch.) Oh, someone didn't come home last night? Must've been gettin' LUCKAYYYYY! No need to worry about a teenage girl's safety or whereabouts or anything. And my fave: Sadie's from Portland and likes pizza-and-movie dates? And she dares to initiate lip-touching with menfolk? OMG THAT POOR TRASHY SKANK. Can't any of them see how utterly fucked up this mentality is?! (To Lizzie Friend's credit, this kind of talk is very deliberately problematic when it's coming from some of the characters. Some.)

The worst part is that I don't even find this kind of attitude unrealistic AT ALL. I would completely buy Friend's dialogue as authentic. But that doesn't mean I have to like it. It's almost been a decade* since Mean Girls; have we learned NOTHING?!

*Trufax. Related: slow the fuck down, time.

Bonus Factor: Boarding School

The boarding school aspect of Keating Hall gets diminished in favour of the other bonus factor -- which is fine, considering how the subplot with Sadie's English noblility twin party girl roommates doesn't really fit in with the rest of the book, and it gets dropped for a huge chunk of the story anyway. Plus, it's kind of contrived that Sadie's living with them, since the the twins' parents are sooooo concerned with confidentiality and the school has double rooms, too. 

Bonus Factor: Secret Society

Man, rich people sure like their shady cults! The Order of Optimates recruits from Keating Hall and its brother school, DeGraffenreid Academy. There's a little bit of 'nyah, nyah, I've got a secret' with the mysteries related to the Order (some of the smaller ones were pretty obvious), but the main one reeeeally ramps up the cray-cray.

Casting Call:

Jane Levy as Sadie

My casting requirement for Sadie was basically "like Emma Stone, but not." So.

Luke Mitchell as Jeremy

And this guy is too old, but only his hotness could make me forget that Jeremy's signature scent is Axe shower gel.

Relationship Status: Frenemies

Poor Little Dead Girls had my heart racing, and my blood boiling. It had no problem keeping my interest, but HOT DAMN, did it ever drive me crazy. Speaking of crazy, this book had it UP THE WAZOO. Fortch, there's juuuust enough good crazy to make me overlook its attitude problem -- until my annoyance with it flared up again, anyway. 

FTC Full Disclosure: I received my free review copy from Merit Press. I received neither money nor froyo for writing this review (dammit!). Poor Little Dead Girls is available now.

Mandy Wan's photo About the Author: Residing in Edmonton, AB, Mandy unabashedly loves YA lit, frozen desserts, and terrible puns.