Book Report: Our highly scientific analysis of a book, from the characters to the writing style to the swoon. See More...

Every Rose Has Its Thorn

Marie Lu's The Young Elites series -- and its main character -- ventures deeper into darkness in the second installment, The Rose Society.

Every Rose Has Its Thorn

BOOK REPORT for The Rose Society (The Young Elites Book 2) by Marie Lu

Cover Story: Hungry Like the (White) Wolf
BFF Charm: Caution!
Swoonworthy Scale: 4
Talky Talk: 2 Fantastical 2 Furious
Bonus Factors: Super-Team Origins, Girl Monarchs
Relationship Status: I Will Follow You Into the Dark

Cover Story: Hungry Like the (White) Wolf

I always appreciate covers that relate to the actual story, but I'll be honest -- if this wasn't a Marie Lu book, the EPIC FANTASY-ness wouldn't do much for me. And out of context, the wolf eyes might seem like surprise lycanthropy is afoot. Which is obviously impossible, since there are no jorts in Kenettra.

The Deal:

WARNING! This is Book 2 of the Young Elites series. Spoilers ahead for Book 1!

SO MANY THINGS HAPPENED, YOU GUYS. After being rescued from her own execution, Adelina and her newfound abilites joined the Dagger Society's fight against the malfetto-hating Inquisition Axis. But soon afterwards, Adelina became a double agent for Lead Inquisitor Teren, who was holding her sister, Violetta, hostage. Adelina eventually rescued Violetta, and she discovered that little sis is a Young Elite herself, with a power that's super handy in stopping the seemingly invincible (and also Young Elite) Teren.

But OH SNAP -- in a moment of confusion, Adelina accidentally incapacitated Dagger Society leader (and occasional makeout partner) Enzo, giving Teren the opportunity to inflict a fatal strike. Which, y'know, he did. Now Enzo's dead, and the Dagger Society has cast Adelina out.

Which is just as well, because she's had enough of being everybody else's pawn anyway. With her sister by her side, Adelina sets out to form her own crew to take down the Inquisition Axis. (So yeah, she's kind of like the kid who gets kicked out of the clubhouse that actually makes good on their promise of starting their own much cooler club that doesn't allow any doo-doo head jerkfaces.) But Adelina's always been better at making enemies than friends, and she has plenty of the former hot on her pursuit. 

BFF Charm: Caution!

OK, so I know that logically, I should unfriend Adelina already. If not for common sense, then how about for MY OWN LIFE? I mean, she's always been dangerous, but now she unabashedly enjoys hurting people. Constantly worrying about staying on her good side would be way too stressful of a hang. 

Homicidal tendencies aside, I do love how uncompromising Adelina is with her prickly self.

"You are powerful, mi Adelinetta," she says, "but you have all the charisma of a burnt potato pudding."

"I like burnt potato pudding. It's smoky."

I WISH I KNEW HOW TO QUIT YOU. (No, I don't. #TeamBurntPotatoPudding!)

Swoonworthy Scale: 4

Adelina's still mourning for Enzo, but it's tough to ignore the charisma of the legendary Magiano. Although I'm skeptical that anyone could ever compete with her true love of POWERRRRR.

Outside of Adelina's entanglements, there's a fair bit of S-E-X going on. Practically none of it swoony, or it's even swoon-negative, like Teren's unhealthy and hopeless devotion to the manipulative Queen Giuletta. But YAY at finding out more about Queen Maeve's history with Lucent from the Daggers.

Talky Talk: 2 Fantastical 2 Furious

Anyone who's ever read a Marie Lu book knows that she does NOT mess around, wielding her words with a ruthlessness to rival that of Adelina. In this sequel, Lu continues to build upon an already impressive world. New players are seamlessly integrated into this increasingly bitter clash for power.

Taking the story beyond the boundaries of Kenettra also reveals that malfettos and Young Elites aren't universally despised at all; in some places, they're even revered. The lack of ideological consensus makes so much sense. Heck, the real world can't even agree on something inconsequential like a stupid dress, so OF COURSE there would be differing perspectives on malfettos! And that kind of brilliance is why Marie Lu is among the top of the YA game.

Bonus Factor: Super-Team Origins

The Dagger Society was already a well-oiled machine when Adelina came along, but now we get the whole recruiting and assembling shebang for the Rose Society.

Bonus Factor: Girl Monarchs

How much do I love that the two main countries of this world are ruled by young women? That's not to say their reigns are flawless -- ahem, Giuletta allowing Teren's witch hunt on malfettos -- but I am all for powerful ladies. Even if they're villains. Especially if they're villains.

Casting Call:

The film rights were snapped up earlier this year, and omg these adaptations really need to happen. But until they do, I'll continue adding to my fantasy cast from the first book report.

Vanessa Hudgens as Violetta

Maybe it's typecasting, but I could totally see Vanessa as the sweet-natured Violetta. (Also, Vanessa Hudgens and Shay Mitchell as sisters would make for one unfairly gorgeous family.)

Henry Cavill as Raffaele

The most celebrated consort in all of Kenettra, Raffaele is insanely pretty and irresistible. Obvs, I thought of an FYA fave.

Jason Momoa as Magiano

Just look at that mischievous face. Jason could def. pull off being a charming thief -- of both riches and PANTS HEARTS.

Nina Dobrev as Giuletta, Queen of Kenettra

Because Katherine Pierce would appreciate how Giuletta's always looking out for Number 1.

Eliza Taylor as Maeve, Queen of Beldain


Relationship Status: I Will Follow You Into the Dark

Book, you and Adelina are descending deeper into darkness, and I'm digging the shizz out of it. You've tantalizingly set the stage for what will surely be a grand finale.

FTC Full Disclosure: I received my free review copy from G.P. Putnam's Sons. I received neither money nor froyo for writing this review (dammit!). The Rose Society is available now.

Mandy Wan's photo About the Author: Residing in Edmonton, AB, Mandy unabashedly loves YA lit, frozen desserts, and terrible puns.