About the Book
- Jessica Spotswood
- J. Anderson Coats
- Andrea Roberston (Cremer)
- Y.S. Lee
- Katherine Longshore
- Marie Lu
- Kekla Magoon
- Marissa Meyer
- Saundra Mitchell
- Beth Revis
- Caroline Tung Richmond
- Lindsay Smith
- Robin Talley
- Leslye Walton
- Elizabeth Wein
- Historical Fiction
Cover Story: Who Run The World?
The Best: “El Destinos” by Leslye Walton and “Bonnie and Clyde” by Saundra Mitchell
The Worst Not My Favorite Genre: “High Stakes” by Andrea Cremer
Bonus Factors: American History, Diversity, LGBTQ
Break Glass In Case Of: Dudes Dominating Your History Books
Cover Story: Who Run the World?
(Girls!) I think this cover is pretty effective in getting the “awesome girls throughout history” point across. But let’s be honest, the best thing about this cover is the title, which, according to editor Jessica Spotswood, “is actually a phrase used by President John Adams in a letter to his wife Abigail, when he was talking about involving women in the new U.S. government!”
If I had seen this in a bookstore, I certainly wouldn’t be able to resist picking it up. And if I were that person, I wouldn’t be disappointed—every single story in this collection is well-written. I had a hard time limiting myself to just two favorites for the purpose of this book report, because if we’re honest, I had at least five.
From Alaska to the Atlantic Ocean, 1710 to 1968, and everywhere in between, here are 15 tales of kickass young girls through American history. Although each tale is grounded in history, the genres aren’t—there’s everything from magical realism to fantasy, with the later stories more firmly grounded in reality. Each story ends with an author’s note about the history and research involved.
The Best: “El Destinos” by Leslye Walton
This Latin version of the Greek Fates myth is gorgeously written. You’ll want to dive into the Southwest—at least as Walton describes it.
The Best: “Bonnie and Clyde” by Saundra Mitchell
I love this story of a Depression-era Robin Hood-style bank robber, who is so gleeful about her double life that you just can’t help but be charmed. Yeah, breaking the law is usually bad…but she makes it seem awfully fun.
Again, this was well-written, but the magical high-stakes game was just not my favorite genre.
Bonus Factor: American History
What really sold this book for me was the breadth of history and cultures explored in each story. There’s a lot of “unglamorous” history represented here—sure, there are stories that involve pretty dresses and suitors in beautiful mansions, but that’s such a small chunk of what America has to offer. I loved the varied settings and socioeconomic backgrounds represented.
Bonus Factor: Diversity
As you can see in Simini Blocker’s adorable print, this collection represents young ladies from multiple ethnicities and cultures.
Bonus Factors: LGBTQ
Our heroines aren’t always straight, either!
Break Glass in Case of: Dudes Dominating Your History Books
Getting a little tired of men’s stories dominating the historical record? This anthology is the perfect complement to your history textbooks: fifteen fun glimpses into the lives of women over the past three centuries. You might find yourself falling in love with a different time and place than you ever expected—and thanks to the helpful authors’ notes, you can start researching your own tale.
FTC Full Disclosure: I received my free review copy from Candlewick Press. This review was originally posted on Kirkus Reviews in exchange for monetary compensation, which did not affect or influence my opinions. A Tyranny of Petticoats: 15 Tales of Belles, Bank Robbers, and Other Badass Girls is available now.