About the Book

Title: Saving Montgomery Sole
Published: 2016

Cover Story: Moon Over My Monty
BFF Charm: Big Sister
Swoonworthy Scale: 0
Talky Talk: Party Like It’s 1999
Bonus Factors: Family, Lists, Canadians
Relationship Status: Let’s Just Be Friends

Cover Story: Moon Over My Monty

Sigh, this cover by Eleanor Davis is THE BOMB DOT COM. The artwork itself is gorgeous, but I especially love how it looks like Monty is trying to command the powers of the universe — and it being so much beyond her control. 

The Deal:

Welcome to Aunty, California — which isn’t particularly welcoming to outcasts like sixteen-year-old Montgomery Sole, who’d rather skip out on a pep rally for a Mystery Club meeting. Together with her besties, Thomas and Naoki, Monty explores weird and unexplained phenomena. And her latest obsession is the Eye of the Know, a mysterious crystal amulet that she bought online. The Eye couldn’t possibly help Monty take on bullies at school… could it? But if it could, maybe it’ll be handy in dealing with the town’s narrow-minded newcomers. 

BFF Charm: Big Sister

BFF Charm Big Sister with Clarissa from Clarissa Explains It All's face

I wish nothing but the best for Monty, but girlfriend still has a lot of growing up to do. A nonconformist to a fault, she can be fairly judgmental towards tastes more mainstream than her own. Monty, it’s great that you’re so passionate about your interests, but realize that there are people who feel similarly about things you’ve written off. If that’s how they choose to spend their time, then so be it; the world’s big enough for everyone to enjoy their many and varied hobbies. Just focus on doing YOU.

Swoonworthy Scale: 0

Aside from a former crush that turned out to be a jerk — whose jerkfaceness negates any possible swoon — Monty doesn’t have any love interests. Thomas, however, is constantly going on dates with older men. Which brings out the protective big sister in me again, because THOMAS — you’re only 17! How much older are these gentleman callers, anyway?!?

Talky Talk: Party Like It’s 1999

OK, I have no doubt that there are still plenty of intolerant idiots out there, as current events frequently verifies, but the ones in Aunty feel particularly cartoonish — esp. the vapid popular girls. While there is a measure of ‘don’t judge a book by its cover’ in this story, it’s mostly not concerned with developing the antagonists much beyond their stereotypes.

The book is also not that concerned with making pop culture references that are younger than its characters. It makes sense for someone like Thomas, who watches a lot of old films, but all the references that I spotted date back to the ’90s or earlier*; they’re explained for an actual YA audience, but the explanations are generally preaching to the choir for readers that are a little less Y and a little more A. It’s a choice that stood out to me for not really serve either crowd well.

*It pains me to indirectly call ’90s films old, but it’s been 84 — er, at least 17 years. 

Bonus Factor: Family

A large group of people holding hands and standing on a beach at sunset, with their backs to the camera

Momma Jo, Mama Kate, Monty, and little sister Tesla might have their ups and downs, but the one constant that binds the family together is love. The Soles’ estrangement from Monty’s grandparents is unfortunate, but it’s also unfortunate to have bigots for grandparents, so. 

Bonus Factor: Lists

A person's hand, writing a list of items in a notebook with a pen

Type A that she is, Monty uses a productivity app “designed for overachieving businessmen” to keep track of potential Mystery Club topics, as well as things that she has neither interest in nor understanding of. 

Bonus Factor: Canadians

The Flag of Canada

Naoki and Monty’s family are all from the maple syrup paradise, so YAY CANADA! (Full disclosure: as is this reviewer, who is also suddenly referring to herself in the third person. She’ll stop now. And not to generalize too much, but pointing out Canadians in pop culture is a pretty Canadian thing to do, so this fulfills my patriotic duty.)

Relationship Status: Let’s Just Be Friends

When this book asked me out, there was no way I could say ‘no’ to that pretty cover or the brains behind its story. But we didn’t hit it off like I hoped we would, and, to be honest, I started contemplating my escape early on. I ended up sticking around, and we became better friends than I had thought possible — but, man, it was a road to get there. So let’s not push our luck by doubling down on this friendship, OK? I’ll see you around the hallways. 

FTC Full Disclosure: I received my free review copy from Roaring Brook Press. This review was originally posted on Kirkus Reviews in exchange for monetary compensation, which did not affect or influence my opinions. Saving Montgomery Sole is available now.

Mandy (she/her) lives in Edmonton, AB. When she’s not raiding the library for YA books, she enjoys eating ice cream (esp. in cold weather), learning fancy pole dance tricks, and stanning BTS. Mandy has been writing for FYA since 2012, and she’s been overseeing all things FYA Book Club since 2013.